8.11 Wrapping Up: What is Gender?

The concept of gender

Above we defined the sexes by the size of gamete produced.  The terms sex and gender are often used interchangeably.  However, for our discussions we will distinguish between the terms.  The American Psychological Association states, “Gender refers to the socially constructed roles, behaviors, activities, and attributes that a given society considers appropriate for boys and men or girls and women. These influence the ways that people act, interact, and feel about themselves.”  In short, gender has to do with the roles one plays in society and is often influenced, but not necessarily determined, by sex.  Gender roles vary from culture to culture in humans.  For a brief description of some of the varied gender roles across cultures, see Table 1.  Societal roles in non-human animals are harder to interpret, however there is also evidence of more than two gender roles in a number of non-human animals (see discussion of white-throated sparrows and bluegill in the beginning of this chapter).

In recent years there has been growing popular awareness that people do not all identify as the gender commonly associated with the sex they were assigned at birth or conform to the concept of gender as binary (they do not strictly identify as man or woman).  However, historic and linguistic evidence indicates that non-binary gender is not a new phenomenon and can be observed across human cultures in both modern and historic times (see Table 1).  It is worth noting that while we learned earlier that there are genetic factors that can cause a person to have intersex characteristics, most people who do not fit in a gender binary or identify as the opposite gender from the sex they were assigned at birth, do not have any identifiable genetic condition associated with sex.

  Read More

The link has some excellent tips on how to be supportive to someone who is gender non-binary or transgender. https://www.glaad.org/transgender/allies

The white-throated sparrow and the bluegill and the great diversity of sex and gender presentations in humans and other sexually reproducing organisms illustrate that sex and gender are complicated.  Our idea of sex as binary is imperfect at best.  The idea that gender is beyond binary is supported by biology, sociology, and history.

Studies of and discussions of sex and gender can be controversial.  Any discussion of sex and gender is almost certain to make at least some participants uncomfortable.  However, there are fascinating aspects of the biology surrounding sex and the sociology surrounding gender that make exploration into these topics worthwhile. Our understanding of sex determination is growing rapidly, and our understanding of the relationship between sex and gender is in its infancy.

Location Name Description Notes
Brazil viado/travestís  male who dresses and presents in a feminine manner
 Europe  sworn virgins of the Balkans  female who participates  masculine roles  sworn virgins stayed with their family and inherited family land (often sworn virgins were in families with no male heirs).  Also worthy of note: there are a number of saints (St. Eugenia, St. Pelagius, St. Wilgefortis, St. Joan) who had varying degrees of assuming a masculine role in society.
 Hawaii and Tahiti  māhū  male who dresses and presents in a feminine manner
India  hijra  born as male, ritually established as third gender. Often dress in feminine clothing. Intersex individuals were often included in this category.  Hijras play an important role in Hindu religious ceramonies
India  sadhin  female who wears men’s clothes and cuts hair short  typically celibate
North America – Navajo  nádleeh

male or female who participates in society in roles typical of the other sex

 North America – Mohave  alyha  male who participates in society in feminine roles  At puberty there is an initiation ceremony during which the child chooses to dance as a female or male, if the child chose the female dance, gender was changed. After this time the alyha’s genitals were referred to using terms for female genitals
 North Ameria – Mohave  hwame  female who participates in society in masculine roles
North America – Cheyenne  hetaneman  female who participates in society in masculine roles
North America – Cocopá warrhameh female who participates in society in masculine roles
North America – Maidu suku female who participates in society in masculine roles
Philippines bayot/bantut/bakla male who adopts feminine roles and presentation
Samoa fa’fafine male who adopts feminine roles and presentation considered very important for family cohesion.
Thailand kathoey male or female who participates in society in roles typical of the other sex.  Intersex individuals are also included in this category In recent years females who present as males are now typically referred to as “tom” from “tomboy”
Tonga fakaletī male who participates in society in feminine roles and presentation
Tuva pinapinaaine male who adopts feminine roles and presentation

  Read More

Most of the information in this table was from the Book Gender Diversity by Serena Nanda.
Note: some (but not all) of the gender roles here are also associated with sexual orientation. For brevity, sexual orientation was not included here. See Nanda’s text for more detail.

As we conclude this chapter and prepare for in-class discussion, be sure to return to the chapter’s goals and objectives.

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

The Evolution and Biology of Sex by Sehoya Cotner and Deena Wassenberg is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.