35 Determining Evolutionary Relationships

Learning Objectives

After exploring this chapter, you should be able to

  • Distinguish homologous from analogous traits using examples.
  • Explain how convergent evolution produces analogous traits.
  • Identify shared ancestral and shared derived characters on a phylogenetic tree.
  • Explain the role of an outgroup in a phylogenetic analysis.
  • Classify a named group as monophyletic or polyphyletic using a phylogenetic tree.
  • Explain how DNA comparisons can test and correct a classification built on physical similarity.
  • Apply maximum parsimony to choose between two alternative phylogenetic trees.

 

Scientists must collect accurate information that allows them to make evolutionary connections among organisms. Similar to detective work, scientists must use evidence to uncover the facts. In the case of phylogeny, evolutionary investigations focus on two types of evidence: morphologic (form and function) and genetic.

Two Options for Similarities

In general, organisms that share similar physical features and genomes are more closely related than those that do not. We refer to features that overlap both morphologically (in form) and genetically as homologous structures. They stem from developmental similarities that are based on shared evolutionary history. For example, the bones in bat and bird wings are homologous structures: both are modified vertebrate forelimbs (Figure 1).

Photo a shows a bird in flight with a corresponding drawing of a bird wing. Photo b is a bat in flight with a corresponding drawing of a bat wing. Both the bird wing and the bat wing share common bones, analogous to the bones in the arms and fingers of humans. However, in the bat wing, the finger bones are long and separate and form a scaffolding on which the wing's membrane is stretched. In the bird wing, the finger bones are short and fused together at the front of the wing.
Figure 1: Bat and bird wings are homologous structures in terms of the layout of their limb bones, indicating that bats and birds share a common evolutionary past. (credit a: modification of work by Steve Hillebrand, USFWS; credit b: modification of work by U.S. DOI BLM)

Notice it is not simply a single bone, but rather a grouping of several bones arranged in a similar way. The more complex the feature, the more likely any kind of overlap is due to a common evolutionary past. Imagine two people from different countries both inventing a car with all the same parts and in exactly the same arrangement without any previous or shared knowledge. That outcome would be highly improbable. However, if two people both invented a hammer, we can reasonably conclude that both could have the original idea without the help of the other. The same relationship between complexity and shared evolutionary history is true for homologous structures in organisms.

Misleading Appearances

Some organisms are very closely related even though a small genetic change produced a large difference in form, so they look quite different. The reverse also happens: distantly related organisms can look very much alike. This usually happens because both lineages adapted to similar environmental conditions. The independent evolution of similar traits in different lineages, in response to similar selective pressures, is convergent evolution. A similarity that results from convergent evolution rather than shared ancestry is an analogy (also called homoplasy).

Wings are the classic example of analogous structures. Insects, birds, and bats all fly with wings, but insect wings have an entirely different structure and embryonic origin from bird and bat wings (Figure 2). Birds and bats also evolved flight separately. Bats are mammals, and their wings evolved long after mammals originated. Birds evolved wings after their lineage split from the lineage leading to crocodiles. The ancestor that birds and bats share had forelimbs but no wings.

Photo a shows a bat wing, photo b shows a bird wing, and photo c shows a honeybee wing, and all three are similar in overall shape. However, the bird wing and bat wing are both made from homologous bones that are similar in appearance. The honeybee wing is made of a thin, membranous material rather than bone.
Figure 2: The (c) wing of a honeybee is similar in shape to a (b) bird wing and (a) bat wing, and it serves the same function. However, the honeybee wing is not composed of bones and has a distinctly different structure and embryonic origin. These wing types (insect versus bat and bird) illustrate an analogy—similar structures that do not share an evolutionary history. (credit a: modification of work by U.S. DOI BLM; credit b: modification of work by Steve Hillebrand, USFWS; credit c: modification of work by Jon Sullivan)

Whether a similarity counts as homology or analogy depends on the comparison. The bones inside bird and bat wings are homologous, because all four-limbed vertebrates inherited the same forelimb bones from a common ancestor. The wings themselves, as structures for flight, are analogous, because flight evolved independently in each lineage. In the same way, the bones in a whale’s flipper are homologous to the bones in a human arm, while a butterfly’s wing and a bird’s wing are analogous and not homologous. Scientists must determine which type of similarity a feature shows before they can use it to reconstruct a phylogeny.

 

Three photos side by side: a blue shark, a king penguin swimming underwater, and a dolphin leaping from the sea. A fish, a bird, and a mammal, all with similar streamlined bodies that evolved independently.
Figure 3. Convergent evolution of a streamlined body. The blue shark (a fish), the king penguin (a bird), and the dolphin (a mammal) evolved similar torpedo-shaped bodies independently, as each lineage adapted to moving quickly through water. Their shared shape is an analogy, not a homology. credit: Charlie Willis, compiled from: blue shark by Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0; king penguin by Manfred Werner, CC BY-SA 4.0; dolphin by safaritravelplus, CC0; all via Wikimedia Commons. Photos cropped, resized, and labeled. Figure licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

Lecture Video: Monophyletic taxa, outgroups, and the primate tree.

Sorting homologies from analogies

Lecture Video: Convergent evolution, paraphyletic and polyphyletic groups, and DNA evidence.

Cladistics uses homologous traits to build a classification and sets analogous traits aside. Consider four animals: a shrew, a bat, a bird, and a crocodile.

Trait Shrew Bat Bird Crocodile
Hair Yes Yes
Scales Yes (legs and feet) Yes
Wings Yes Yes

 

Hair evolved once, in the ancestor of all mammals, so hair is a homology that groups the shrew and the bat. Scales are the ancestral condition for this set of animals, retained by common ancestry in birds and crocodiles. Wings evolved separately in bats and birds, so they are an analogy and carry no information about relatedness. The answer is two pairs: shrew with bat, and bird with crocodile. The bat and the bird share wings, but the bird’s closest relative in this set is the crocodile.

Molecular Comparisons

The advancement of DNA technology has given rise to molecular systematics, the use of molecular data in taxonomy and biological geography (biogeography). DNA sequencing reads the order of bases along a stretch of DNA, and the sequences of two species can be compared base by base. Species that share a more recent common ancestor have had less time to accumulate differences, so their sequences are more similar. Early methods estimated relatedness more indirectly, by measuring how tightly single strands of DNA from two species bonded to each other. Current methods compare sequences directly, often across whole genomes. New computer programs not only confirm many earlier classifications but also uncover errors.

DNA evidence has corrected classifications that rested on appearance. For a long time, whales were thought to be close relatives of carnivores such as dogs and bears, because whales are predators and early fossil whale skulls had carnivore-like teeth. DNA comparisons instead grouped whales with hoofed mammals, and specifically with hippopotamuses and then pigs. In the early 2000s, fossils of early whales with well-preserved ankle bones confirmed that their ancestors had hooves, not claws. Despite the fact that a hippopotamus looks more like a pig than a whale, the hippopotamus appears to be the whale’s closest living relative.

As with physical characteristics, DNA can be tricky to read. Two closely related organisms can appear unrelated if a mutation inserted or deleted a base in one of them, shifting every downstream base by one position so that otherwise similar sequences no longer line up. In other cases, segments of DNA in distantly related organisms share many of the same bases by chance, making the organisms appear closely related when they are not. Computer methods help identify the real relationships in both situations, and combining morphological and molecular information is more effective than using either alone.

EVOLUTION CONNECTION


Why Does Phylogeny Matter?

Evolutionary biologists could list many reasons why understanding phylogeny is important to everyday life in human society. For botanists, phylogeny acts as a guide to discovering new plants that can be used to benefit people. Think of all the ways humans use plants—food, medicine, and clothing are a few examples. If a plant contains a compound that is effective in treating cancer, scientists might want to examine all of the compounds for other useful drugs.

A research team in China identified a DNA segment that they thought to be common to some medicinal plants in the family Fabaceae (the legume family). They worked to identify which species had this segment (Figure 4). After testing plant species in this family, the team found a DNA marker (a known location on a chromosome that enabled them to identify the species) present. Then, using the DNA to uncover phylogenetic relationships, the team could identify whether a newly discovered plant was in this family and assess its potential medicinal properties.

The illustration shows a Dalbergia sissoo plant, which is short with pods and teardrop-shaped leaves.
Figure 4: Dalbergia sissoo (D. sissoo) is in the Fabaceae, or legume family. Scientists found that D. sissoo shares a DNA marker with species within the Fabaceae family that have antifungal properties. Subsequently, researchers found that D. sissoo had fungicidal activity, supporting the idea that DNA markers are useful to screen plants with potential medicinal properties.

Building Phylogenetic Trees

How do scientists construct phylogenetic trees? After they sort homologous from analogous traits, scientists often organize the homologous traits using cladistics. This system sorts organisms into clades: groups of organisms that descended from a single ancestor, including all of that ancestor’s descendants. For example, in Figure 5, all the organisms in the orange region evolved from a single ancestor that had amniotic eggs. Consequently, these organisms also have amniotic eggs and make a single clade, or a monophyletic group. Clades must include all descendants from a branch point.

VISUAL CONNECTION


The illustration shows the V-shaped Vertebrata clade, which includes lancelets, lampreys, fish, lizards, rabbits, and humans. Lancelets are at the left tip of the V, and humans are at the right tip. Four more lines are drawn parallel to the lancelet line; each of these lines starts further up the right arm of the V than the next. At the end of each line, from left to right, are lampreys, fish, lizards, and rabbits. Lizards, rabbits, and humans are in the clade Amniota, which form a small V nested in the upper right-hand corner of the V-shaped Vertebrata clade.
Figure 5: Lizards, rabbits, and humans all descend from a common ancestor that had an amniotic egg. Thus, lizards, rabbits, and humans all belong to the clade Amniota. Vertebrata is a larger clade that also includes fish and lamprey.

 

  1. Which animals in this figure belong to a clade that includes animals with hair
  2. Which evolved first, hair or the amniotic egg?


Answers:
1. Rabbits and humans belong in the clade that includes animals with hair.
2. The amniotic egg evolved before hair because the Amniota clade is larger than the clade that encompasses animals with hair.

Clades can vary in size depending on which branch point one references. The important factor is that all organisms in the clade stem from a single point on the tree. You can remember this because monophyletic breaks down into “mono,” meaning one, and “phyletic,” meaning evolutionary relationship. Figure 6 shows various clade examples. Notice how each clade comes from a single point, whereas the non-clade groups show branches that do not share a single point.

VISUAL CONNECTION


Illustrations show a phylogenetic tree that includes eukaryotic species. A central line represents the trunk of the tree. From this trunk, various groups branch. In order from the bottom, these are diplomonads, microsporidia, trichomonads, flagellates, entamoebae, slime molds, and ciliates. At the top of the tree, animals, fungi and plants all branch from the same point and are shaded to show that they belong in the same clade. Flagellates are on a branch by themselves, and they also form their own clade and are shaded to show this. In another image, Flagellates and ciliates are shaded to show that they branch from different points on the tree and are not considered clades. Likewise, a grouping of animals and plants but not fungi would not be considered a clade cannot exclude a branch originating at the same point as the others.
Figure 6: All the organisms within a clade stem from a single point on the tree. A clade may contain multiple groups, as in the case of animals, fungi and plants, or a single group, as in the case of flagellates. Groups that diverge at a different branch point, or that do not include all groups in a single branch point, are not clades.

 

What is the largest clade in this diagram?


Answer:
The largest clade encompasses the entire tree.

Outgroups

To judge how closely the species of interest are related to one another, a tree needs a reference point outside the group. An outgroup is a taxon known to have diverged before the group being studied. It anchors the tree and shows which traits are ancestral. In Figure 5, for instance, lancelets, which are non-vertebrates,  serve as the outgroup for the remaining vertebrate lineages; the branch point between lancelets and the other vertebrates on the tree sits farthest from the tips, which means it happened longest ago.

Shared Characteristics

Organisms evolve from common ancestors and then diversify. Scientists use the phrase “descent with modification” because even though related organisms have many of the same characteristics and genetic codes, changes occur. This pattern repeats as one goes through the phylogenetic tree of life:

  1. A change in an organism’s genetic makeup leads to a new trait which becomes prevalent in the group.
  2. Many organisms descend from this point and have this trait.
  3. New variations continue to arise: some are adaptive and persist, leading to new traits.
  4. With new traits, a new branch point is determined (go back to step 1 and repeat).

If a characteristic is found in the ancestor of a group, it is considered a shared ancestral character because all of the organisms in the taxon or clade have that trait. The vertebrate in Figure 5 is a shared ancestral character. Now consider the amniotic egg characteristic in the same figure. Only some of the organisms in Figure 5 have this trait, and to those that do, it is called a shared derived character because this trait derived at some point but does not include all of the ancestors in the tree.

The tricky aspect to shared ancestral and shared derived characters is that these terms are relative. We can consider the same trait one or the other depending on the particular diagram that we use. Returning to Figure 5, note that the amniotic egg is a shared ancestral character for the Amniota clade, while having hair is a shared derived character for some organisms in this group. These terms help scientists distinguish between clades in building phylogenetic trees.

Choosing the Right Relationships

Imagine being the person responsible for organizing all department store items properly—an overwhelming task. Organizing the evolutionary relationships of all life on Earth proves much more difficult: scientists must span enormous blocks of time and work with information from long-extinct organisms. Trying to decipher the proper connections, especially given the presence of homologies and analogies, makes the task of building an accurate tree of life extraordinarily difficult. Add to that advancing DNA technology, which now provides large quantities of genetic sequences for researchers to use and analzye. Taxonomy is a subjective discipline: many organisms have more than one connection to each other, so each taxonomist will decide the order of connections.

To aid in the tremendous task of describing phylogenies accurately, scientists often use the concept of maximum parsimony, which means that events occurred in the simplest, most obvious way. For example, if a group of people entered a forest preserve to hike, based on the principle of maximum parsimony, one could predict that most would hike on established trails rather than forge new ones.

For scientists deciphering evolutionary pathways, the same idea is used: the pathway of evolution probably includes the fewest major events that coincide with the evidence at hand. Starting with all of the homologous traits in a group of organisms, scientists look for the most obvious and simple order of evolutionary events that led to the occurrence of those traits.

LINK TO LEARNING


Learn how researchers use maximum parsimony to create phylogenetic trees.

These tools and concepts are only a few strategies scientists use to tackle the task of revealing the evolutionary history of life on Earth. Recently, newer technologies have uncovered surprising discoveries with unexpected relationships, such as the fact that people seem to be more closely related to fungi than fungi are to plants. Sound unbelievable? As the information about DNA sequences grows, scientists will become closer to mapping the evolutionary history of all life on Earth.

Glossary

analogy
(also, homoplasy) characteristic that is similar between organisms by convergent evolution, not due to the same evolutionary path
cladistics
system to organize homologous traits to describe phylogenies
maximum parsimony
applying the simplest, most obvious way with the least number of steps
molecular systematics
technique using molecular evidence to identify phylogenetic relationships
monophyletic group
(also, clade) organisms that share a single ancestor
shared ancestral character
describes a characteristic on a phylogenetic tree that all organisms on the tree share
shared derived character
describes a characteristic on a phylogenetic tree that only a certain clade of organisms share

Access for free at https://openstax.org/books/biology-2e/pages/1-introduction

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Introductory Biology Copyright © by will1278 and Various Authors - See Each Chapter Attribution is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.